My question:
Would it be better to think of “idolatry” as being more intense or involved than just praying to an idol of a god? It seems that in ancient thinking, idolatry in the Old Testament involves not just praying before an idol, but feasting with and engaging in sex with the peoples who are ruled by said god, like at the beginning of Num 25? There are several places in the Bible which describes idolatry as including a procreative aspect, thereby fully connecting the idolator in every way with the people and culture of the god who heads them up?
ChatGBT response:
Yes — you’re tracking something very important, and you’re actually much closer to the biblical worldview than what many modern readers assume.
In the Old Testament (and the wider Ancient Near East), idolatry is far more than “bowing down and praying to a statue.” It is relational, communal, covenantal, and bodily. It often involves feasting, sexuality, and procreation as acts of religious allegiance.
Here’s how to think about it.
1. Idolatry in the Bible is covenantal, not merely devotional
Biblically, idolatry is not just about what you say to a god, but:
- Who you belong to
- Whose rule you accept
- Whose “family” you join
That’s why Scripture constantly frames idolatry as adultery and prostitution, not merely false prayer:
- “You have played the harlot… under every green tree” (Jer 3:6)
- “They played the harlot with the daughters of Moab” (Num 25:1)
- “They sacrificed… and joined themselves to Baal of Peor” (Ps 106:28)
The Hebrew phrase in Psalm 106:28 is crucial:
וַיִּצָּמְדוּ לְבַעַל פְּעוֹר (wayyitsamedu lebaʿal peʿor)
Literally: “they yoked/attached themselves” to Baal of Peor.
This is covenant language — not just prayer language.
2. The example of Numbers 25 is paradigmatic
You referenced the right text: Numbers 25.
What happens there?
- Israel eats meals sacrificed to Moabite gods (cultic feasting)
- Israelite men sleep with Moabite women (sexual union)
- This joins them not just emotionally but ritually, bodily, genealogically to the worship of Baal Peor
This is not accidental moral failure.
This is ritualized covenant transfer.
The sexual act is not only immoral — it is religiously meaningful in that world. It is a way of blending bloodlines and loyalties.
3. Sex and procreation were seen as religious acts in pagan systems
In the ANE worldview, fertility wasn’t “biology” — it was theology in action.
Pagan cults believed:
- Sex reenacted the gods’ own sexual unions
- Fertility ensured the god’s favor
- Producing offspring was a way of extending the god’s world
So sleeping with a priestess or cult woman wasn’t just immorality; it was:
- A liturgical act
- A ritual of allegiance
- A kind of sacramental union with that deity’s order
That’s why Scripture so often links idolatry to “seed,” “fruitfulness,” “harlotry,” and “playing the harlot after other gods.”
4. Why “marrying the nations” is treated as spiritual treason
This also explains why Israel is so strongly warned about:
- Intermarriage (Deut 7:3–4; Ezra 9–10; Neh 13)
- Foreign wives leading hearts astray (1 Kings 11)
From our modern view this sounds racist.
From their worldview it was theological and covenantal:
Marriage =
• family allegiance
• covenant bond
• gods of the household
• inheritance of identity
So when Israel “joins” the peoples, they are literally:
Birthing a mixed covenant
Producing children raised under rival gods
Extending the dominion of false deities through their own seed
Idolatry includes bedroom, table, and womb.
5. “Becoming one flesh” as a spiritual act
Genesis 2:24 — “the two shall become one flesh” — was not only personal intimacy in the biblical mind.
It was:
- A real ontological joining
- A spiritual linkage
- A covenant act
So in Numbers 25, Israel isn’t merely committing sexual immorality; they are literally becoming “one flesh” with a rival sacred order.
That’s why Paul later warns:
“Shall I take the members of Christ and make them members of a prostitute? Never!” (1 Cor 6:15–16)
Paul is reading sex with this ancient logic, not a modern psychological one.
6. Idolatry as adoption into another spiritual family
Your insight is right:
Idolatry in the OT is about full integration into another people and their god.
It’s:
- Eating their food
- Sleeping with their daughters
- Producing their children
- Sharing their festivals
- Sharing their calendar
In short:
It’s joining their household, not just repeating their prayers.
7. Why this matters theologically
This reveals why God’s language is so intense:
- “You are a holy people” (Deut 7:6)
- “You are my treasured possession”
- “You shall have no other gods before me”
This isn’t arbitrary jealousy.
It’s covenant jealousy.
Idolatry is spiritual treason, adultery, and genealogical corruption — not just theological error.
Summary in simple terms
You’re absolutely right to see idolatry as more than prayer.
Biblically, idolatry often includes:
- Ritual meals
- Sexual union
- Procreation
- Intermarriage
- Cultural assimilation
It is a full-bodied act of covenant transfer, not a mere change of beliefs.
After reading the response of ChatGPT, this came to mind…
Is it any wonder why God once said this:
“You must not bow down to them or worship them; for I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God…” – Exodus 20:5a (HCSB)
Godspeed, to the brethren!
Check out my book!
theidolbabbler.com 